The Southside Whisky Club  

Miltonduff 1998 (Berry Bros & Rudd 2011) | 57.0% | Speyside
Fruity Sweet Chili heat Flavour Profile Search
Distillery Info
Miltonduff Distillery, Scotland     founded: 1824 | active
For more detailed mapping of the distilleries in the area from our whisky map page, use this link.

Meet Deets
Meet #36   |   09/03/13   |   Hosted by Fran
We thought it was time to tackle a couple of distilleries that no one in the club had tried before. The newly reopened Glenglassaugh Distillery was up against a Berry Bros. & Rudd Miltonduff bottling.
Other bottles sampled:
#65 Glenglassaugh Revival | SSWC review 36a
Fruity and perhaps a little musty, with melons, pear drops, California raisins, apricots and apple juice forming a team known only as "Fruitronic", whilst coffee, damp woodland and tobacco are all giving it some for Team Musty... before battle, the two teams feast on sweet treats of honey, Cointreau, honeycomb, molasses and Crunchie bars. Once the fighting is over, the wounds are carefully washed with a little rose water and patched up with some plasters... who knows who the victor was, it's a fictional battle between flavours, logic doesn't really apply.
An eclectic and interesting mix of flavours presented themselves in the mouth: mustard, sun-blushed tomatoes, sugar snap peas, cucumber, blue cheese and coriander made for a good savoury quotient, whilst orange rind, roses, sticky toffee pudding, flambed raisins, chili jam, (heather) honey, dates and fruit pastilles headed up the sweet opposition. The mustiness from the nose has mostly been replaced by this sweetness whilst the fruitiness prevails, along with the rose flavours, this time helped along the way with beeswax instead of plasters.

  Most Miltonduff goes into Ballantine's blends... how will their single malt fare?
Finish & Comments
Length was split wide open between tasters, with long, medium and short all offered up... on average, this one comes out at medium-long ("a thoughtful hug"). Sea salt and seaweed introduce a new saltiness to proceedings and burnt straw, crackers and old mead bring back a bit of the mustiness from the nose. Fermented lemon juice and baklava show the variety available after it's gone, whilst perfume by mistake adds in a bit of scented confusion to wrap things up.
~£53 (70cl)
Useful Links
WhiskyBase: Miltonduff 1998   |
We've always scored out of 10 in our group (see number in red box, below), with scores regularly given across that spectrum. The value out of 100 below is adjusted to the scale most commonly used for whisky reviews, to allow for better comparison.

68 / 100

Average score

Detailed scores (out of 10)
Fran: 5.3
Hamish: 5.9
Iain: 6.1
Laura: 5.5
Liz: 5.3
Lucy: 4.7
Martin: 5.8
Phil: 6.6
Shelley: 6.3
Tasting Game Points (out of 6)
Fran: N/A
Hamish: 1
Iain: 0.5
Laura: 0
Liz: 1.5
Lucy: 1
Martin: 1
Phil: 1
Shelley: 1


[ for other thoughts on whisky and more in-depth activities of the group, check out whisky on meiotic ]