Benromach Organic Review - Southside Whisky Club

grains

sswc

## Flavour Search

## Annual Awards

## Whisky Rankings

#100d Banff 1971 33yo

#100c SMWS 3.46

#100b Glen Grant 15yo CC

#100a 1979 Sherry Butt Blend

#99b SMWS 10.158

#99a Adnams Triple Malt

#98e Strathearn 3yo Oloroso

#98d Bowmore 1997 Adelphi

#98c Dalmore Port Cask

#98b Glen Scotia 1989 Cask

#98a Daftmill Summer Release

#97b SMWS 66.116 Ardmore 10yo

#97a SMWS 58.24

#96e Smokehead High Voltage

#96d Smögen 7yo Barrique

#96c Slyrs 3yo Single Cask

#96b Samaroli 1995/2016 Speyside

#96a Mystery New Make (Scottish)

#95b Laphroaig 2005 CWC 12yo

#95a SMWS 9.144

#94d Arran Bothy 1/4 Cask

#94c Deanston Bordeaux 9yo

#94b G&M Glenrothes 8yo

#94a Miltonduff Provenance 7yo

#93d Cads Teaninich 11yo

#93c Cads Dailuaine 13yo

#93b Cads Balmenach 13yo

#93a Ben Bracken Highland

#92d G&M Bunnahabhain 2006

#92c SMWS 63.44

#92b SMWS 35.197

#92a G + M Clynelish 2000

#91e An Cnoc 35yo

#91d Arran RMW Single Cask

#91c Benriach Peated #1

#91b Willett's Rye

#91a An Cnoc 12yo

#90b SMWS 10.134

#90a SMWS 36.138

#89c SMWS 77.45

#89b WS Islay 8yo

#89a WS Speyside 12yo

#88b Bunnahabhain 2005

#88a G&M Glen Keith 1997

#87b SMWS 64.82 13yo

#87a Ledaig 18yo Boutique-y

#86b Cad's Glen Elgin 21

#86a Cad's Glen Ord 10

#85b Braeval OP 18yo

#84d Glenglassaugh PC

#84c Floki Sheep Dung

#84b SMWS 93.71

#84a Taketsuru Pure Malt

#83c Bruichladdich 24yo Cads

#83b Highland Park 20yo Cads

#83a Bunnahabhain 16yo Cads

#82 Auchroisk 27yo

#81e Tomatin 14yo Port

#81d Port Askaig 100

#81c Amrut Portonova #12

#81b Westport 2006 WhB

#81a Arran Port Finish

#80c Lagavulin 7yo Cad's

#80b Talisker Dark Storm

#80a Talisker 10yo

#79b Springbank 12yo CS

#79a Macduff 9yo WB

#78c Kininvie 1991 23yo

#78b Cu Bocan 1988

#78a Port Dundas 1988

#77c Hazelburn 12yo

#77b Imperial G&M 1996

#77a Cadenhead Creations 17yo

#76c SMWS 30.91 Glenrothes 18yo

#76b Ailsa Bay Inaugural

#76a High West Campfire

#75d Islay House Malt 9yo

#75c The Trojan 25yo

#75b Abbey Anon 14yo

#75a Irish 14yo Nectar

#73b SMWS 66.82

#73a Lagavulin 8yo

#72f Daluaine F&F

#72e Glenkinchie 28yo

#72d Glenkinchie 14yo

#72c Glenkinchie Distillers 2015

#72b Glenkinchie 12yo

#72a Glenkinchie Distillers 2006

#71c Octomore 7.2

#71b Octomore 6.1

#71a G&M Linkwood 15yo

#70d Raasay Tuscan Cask

#70c SMWS C1 Cognac

#70b Speyside 18yo

#70a Kingsbarns Spirit Drink

#69b Clynelish 1998 15yo

#69a Teaninich F&F

#68b Willowbank DW 15yo

#68a Highland Park 2006

#67d Amrut Peated CS

#67c Kavalan Sherry Oak

#67b North British 6yo

#66 Mackmyra Midnattssol

#65c Cadenhead Creations 23yo

#65b Tobermory 20yo 1994

#65a Glen Moray 16yo Cdn

#64c Auchentoshan 15yo SB

#64b Kilkerran WiP 7 SC

#64a Kilchoman Loch Gorm

#63b Ben Nevis 49yo

#63a Springbank 10yo 1990s

#62c Longrow 12yo CS

#62b Benriach 12yo Sherry

#62a Tomatin Cù Bòcan VO

#61e Woodford Reserve

#61d FEW Single Malt

#61c Elijah Craig 12yo

#61b Balcones Brimstone

#61a Dry Fly Wheat CS

#60c Ledaig 17yo 1997

#60b Hazelburn 11yo 2000

#60a Jura SM 2008

#59b Aberlour Sauternes 19yo

#59a Linkwood Claret 24yo

#58b Glen Grant 21yo WS

#58a Jameson 15yo (1970s)

#57d Chichibu Chibidaru

#57c SMWS 27.107

#57b Edradour Super Tuscan

#57a Glen Moray 10yo

#56b Hellyers Road Pinot

#56a Sullivans Cove DC

#55b Cooley 2005 13yo

#55a Port Ellen OMC 26yo

#54 Ben Nevis 1998

#53c SMWS 129.2

#53b SMWS 120.5

#53a SMWS 76.74

#52c Glen Scotia 12yo

#52b Glen Spey 1995 CC

#52a Bladnoch SV 20yo

#51b Three Ships 10yo

#51a Mackmyra 5yo

#50c SMWS 4.191

#50b Kilchoman 100% #3

#50a Adnams Malt #1

#49 Elements Lp4

#48 Dà Mhìle LL 12yo

#47b Glendronach 1994

#47a Benromach Organic

#46b WS Islay 25yo

#46a Glen Elgin 22yo

#45b Via Saum Behm Wiski

#45a SMWS 132.6

#44b Caol Ila 1991 17yo

#44a Nectar D'or

#43 Royal Lochnagar 12yo

#42b Bruichladdich Organic

#42a MacDuff 14yo 1997

#41b Tomintoul Peaty Tang

#41a Arran Amarone Cask

#40b Laphroaig 15yo DC

#40a Glenlivet 25yo

#39a SMWS G10.1

#38c Powers John's Lane 12yo

#38b Green Spot

#37e Yamazaki 18yo

#37d Hakushu 12yo

#37c Karuizawa Asama

#37b Nikka Coffey Grain

#37a Yoichi 10yo

#36b Miltonduff 1998

#36a Glenglassaugh Revival

#35b Lagavulin Jazz 2012

#35a Lagavulin New Make

#34c SMWS 33.122

#34a Bowmore 12yo

#33c As We Get It - Islay 8yo

#33b BenRiach Importanticus

#33a CB The Spice Tree

#32 Christmas 2012

#31b Clynelish 1998 13yo

#31a Scapa 16yo

#30b Kilkerran WiP 3

#30a Kilchoman 5yo

#29b Talisker 10yo

#29a Rundlets & Kilderkins

#28b Tullibardine Moscatel

#28a Glenturret 15yo

#27 North British DC 50yo

#26b SMWS 84.14

#26a Glenmorangie Lasanta

#25c SMWS 66.35

#25a Twat's Reserve

#24 Caol Ila Moch

#23 Rum Tasting

#22b Elements Lp1

#22a Elements Bn1

#21b Mortlach 20yo WS

#21a WoodWinters 23yo

#20c Weller Wheated

#20b Rittenhouse Rye

#20a Mellow Corn

#19b MoM Highland-P 13yo

#19a MoM Orkney 12yo

#18 Elements Kh1

#17 Whisky Cocktail Night

#16b Bladnoch 1990 20yo

#16a Glenkinchie 1989

#15b Benromach Sassicaia

#15a Benromach PX

#14 Whisky Fringe 2011

#13 Bruichladdich PC7

#12b Laphroaig 1/4 Cask

#12a Bruichladdich Peat

#11b Glencadam Portwood

#11a Blair Athol 12yo

#10 Fettercairn 17yo 1993

#9d Elements Ar2

#9c Nikka 'From The Barrel'

#9b Redbreast 12yo

#9a Sazerac Rye

#8b Lagavulin PX 94

#8a Elements Lg1

#7 Official Tasting

#6 Black Bull 12yo

#5 Glen Ord 28yo

#3 Longrow 10yo

#2 Ardbeg Blasda

#1 Aberlour A'bunadh

The Southside Whisky Club

Benromach Organic | 43.0% | Speyside

91

86

47

Sour

Chili heat

Sweet

Distillery Info

Benromach Distillery, Scotland founded: 1898 | active
For more detailed mapping of the distilleries in the area from our whisky map page, use this link.

Meet Deets

Meet #47 | 01/03/14 | Hosted by Hamish
A couple of interesting whiskies forming a sort of 'new and old' evening. A young, virgin oak Benromach offering the youthful and modern side of things, whilst an older, heavily-sherried Glendronach would be all refined and rich...

Other bottles sampled:
#92 Glendronach 1994 | SSWC review 47b
Aberlour 10yo | Not reviewed
Caol Ila 12yo | Not reviewed
Glenkinchie 10yo | Not reviewed
Laphroaig 10yo | Not reviewed

Smells

Hay/Hey! Pine cleaner, Playdough (double!), metal, Strawberry Toffos, hot lemon (not sexy). Unripe stewed rhubarb, post-cocaine back-nose dribble (hints of), rosewater, sweet fresh oak, a distant chemical toilet, feijoa (A made-up fruit from NZ), a minimal stir-fry cooked by Ali Lloyd involving soy sauce, 5 spice, courgette, lime juice, chicken and garlic, delicious. Iain says it smells nothing like Playdough or a stir-fry.

Tastes

Dry & sour, incredibly sour sweets, Phil says it tastes like delicious cock, buttery, a lack of woody sweetness, feijoa, TOTAL FUCKING CHAOS, chocolate, o(a)k, slated butter, black pepper burn, burnt rubber, burnt toast, intriguing, "I'm starting to think this could be a bad idea".

Our hosts were pretty excited about the night's potential..

Finish & Comments

Metallic, 'no idea', treacle, lemon tart, really good finish, medium-long (a 19 yard drive in football speak), Herby goes Bananas (isn't a banana a herb?).

Cost

~£38 (70cl)

Useful Links

Royal Mile Whiskies: Benromach Organic | http://www.royalmilewhiskies.com/product.asp?

Rating

We've always scored out of 10 in our group (see number in red box, below), with scores regularly given across that spectrum. The value out of 100 below is adjusted to the scale most commonly used for whisky reviews, to allow for better comparison.

69 / 100

5.8

Average score

Detailed scores (out of 10)

Ali: 5.4
Andy: 6.6
Charlotte: 5
Giles: 6
Hamish: 6.4
Iain: 6.5
Laura: 5
Liz: 5.8
Phil: 6.7
Scott: 4

Tasting Game Points (out of 0)

No scores available.

[ for other thoughts on whisky and more in-depth activities of the group, check out whisky on meiotic ]